Saffron or Rosemary?

I have one baby girl Eulalia Chiara (Elsie) and am expecting twin girls. One I will definitely be naming Isla and the other either Saffron or Rosemary (Rosy/Romey). Whichever one I don't use as a first name I will use as a middle name...Atalanta being my other chosen middle name.



So in other words - which do you prefer:

Isla Saffron and Rosemary Atalanta

or Isla Rosemary and Saffron Atalanta?
Saffron or Rosemary?
Eulalia is a beautiful name.



Isla sounds like it could be an old-fashioned classic...pretty.



so i'd go with Rosemary. like the song, that's who i am (rosemary's granddaughter).



i think it fits with the others better and it's prettier.



saffron sounds like a spice or something.



so i think you should go with Isla Saffron and Rosemary Atalanta. then they'll both have "unique" middle names. =]



congratulations on twins by the way! =]
Reply:Isla Rosemary and Saffron Atalanta
Reply:advance congrats!

isla saffron and rosemary atlanta
Reply:Saffron sounds very modern where as Isla doesn't so Isla and Rosemary would sound better than Isla and Saffron but i think Rosemary is way too old fashioned.

There is a girl in my sons class called Saffron, i really like it for a girl.
Reply:I don't like Rosemary sorry.



But I love Saffron Atlanta.
Reply:isla saffron. that's really a very nice name!
Reply:Are you looking to your spice rack for inspiration? How unfortunate.
Reply:I don't love Atalanta at all, but I do like both Saffron and Rosemary. I think Saffron is a more modern, hip sort of nature name, where Rosemary is a more soft, old-fashioned sort of nature name. Based on your other daughter's names, I think Rosemary is the choice that fits better with Isla and Eulalia. I think Isla Saffron and Rosemary Ariadne would be very nice.
Reply:Isla Saffron and Rosemary Atalanta. although i prefer Atalanta Rosemary.
Reply:Isla and Rosemary seem a better fit than Isla and Saffron! Rosemary is such a gorgeous, old-fashioned name and goes really well with the classic sound of Isla (eye-luh, I think), while Saffron sounds a bit too harsh and modern to go with the soft femininity of Isla and Eulalia / Elsie. Romey too is a really pretty nickname that would sound so sweet with her twin Isla.



Good luck and congrats!!
Reply:Why not Thyme or Curry or Basil or Oregano. Oh, what about Chili that way you can be just tlike the girl from TLC. What about Cinnamon, Allspice, Nutmeg, (just thinking about what I have in my cabinets) Oh, oh, oh....what about naming the twins Salt and Pepper?
Reply:I hope you are kidding? Go with Salt and Pepa instead..much more trendy.
Reply:Are you naming a baby or making a chicken?



I feel for your child for all the taunts and teasing while growing up.
Reply:Isla Saffron and Rosemary Atalanta
Reply:Rosemary Isla and --- Saffron. I'm sorry, but Atalanta just looks like a misspelling of Atlanta, and isn't very appealing. Saffron would be a better middle name than a first. Congrats and good luck!



Besides, do you really want your dughter to be named after Atalanta Athletic Gear???
Reply:Rosemary is more old-fashioned and cuter.
Reply:I'm just mad about Saffron

Saffron's mad about me

sorry lol, I honestly couldn't resist singing Mellow Yellow:)



Seeing as there is much of a choice here,



Isla Saffron and Rosemary Atalanta



Also, I do realize Atalanta is a Goddesses name from Greek Mythology